Armed and dangerous: Stand your ground turns man into Judge Dredd

Judge Dredd / DNA Films
Judge Dredd / DNA Films

MONTGOMERY VILLAGE, Md., February 12, 2014 — Two recent shootings in Florida have resulted in the deaths of two young men. In both cases, stand your ground will be used as the defense for the shooters.

In one case, an elderly, retired police officer shot a young father after an argument about texting. During the argument, the victim apparently hurled a container of popcorn at the shooter.

In the other, the shooter approached a car with four teenagers and asked them to turn down the loud music they were playing. After an exchange of words, the shooter went to his car, took out a gun and fired at the teens. After firing several rounds, he stopped, then resumed firing as the car tried to get away. He then waited for his girlfriend and drove with her to a bed and breakfast 160 miles away. He later told police that he believed someone in the car had a gun; however, his girlfriend testified that he never mentioned the gun after the couple left the gas station. One young man in the car was killed.

This happened after the celebrated shooting of Trayvon Martin by George Zimmerman.

All three shootings took place in Florida, a state with the stand-your-ground defense. The defendants have indicated that they were in fear for their lives when they shot unarmed people.

Just imagine the results if the shooters had not been carrying fire arms. Words might have been exchanged and some fists thrown. Someone’s manhood might have been called into question.

But three people would not be dead.

That seems obvious, but for a lot of people, it is not.

This is a trend that cannot be denied: People are taking chances that otherwise they would not, just because they feel emboldened by having a firearm.

Which comes first: the stand-your-ground defense, or the need to have a fire arm to avoid losing face? Did people who carry firearms lobby for a stand your ground law, or has stand your ground encouraged people to carry firearms to avoid losing face?

Whatever the answer is, stand your ground is a sad way for a first-world country to confront violence in the 21st Century. Are we so afraid of our fellow citizens that we have to think the worst of them, then confirm it by arming ourselves and shooting them?

This is not a question of constitutional rights. The right to bear arms does not include the right to take risks that may result in the loss of life.

Most of us have felt threatened at some time in our lives. We have had these experiences not in combat or as police officers, but as civilians living normal lives. How many of us have thought in those dire situations that we might shoot someone if we had a firearm? It is better to step away from these situations than to stand our ground and risk getting hurt or killed — or worse, to risk killing another who meant us no harm.

The people of Florida have completely changed the paradigm. The new one tells them to go looking for trouble since they are well armed.


Mario Salazar, the 21st Century Pacifist, is on Facebook (Mario Salazar), Twitter (@chibcharus) and Google+

Click here for reuse options!
Copyright 2014 Communities Digital News

• The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the editors or management of Communities Digital News.

This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities Digital News, LLC. Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

Correspondingly, Communities Digital News, LLC uses its best efforts to operate in accordance with the Fair Use Doctrine under US Copyright Law and always tries to provide proper attribution. If you have reason to believe that any written material or image has been innocently infringed, please bring it to the immediate attention of CDN via the e-mail address or phone number listed on the Contact page so that it can be resolved expeditiously.


    Wrong metaphor. The Punisher is the comic character you’re looking for– Dredd isn’t a vigilante but a state-sponsored, fascist law-enforcer.

    • 21st Century Pacifist

      Thank you for reading my article. Regardless of the metaphor, the fact remains that having a weapon makes people braver. No wonder firearms have been called the big equalizer.

  • MoniqueDC

    Stand your ground laws were sponsored by ALEC (check them out ..they are a scary combo of politicians and corp sponsors). I wish there were some way to challenge and stop all such laws from a constitutional perspective.
    Plus in both Florida cases, the prosecution seems to have been very weak. Part of these laws require a sense of imminent harm (and two other criteria), but these situations are not challenged as they should be.
    On your basic premise, Mario, no only does having a gun make people more prone to taking violent action (and to having gun accidents in the home) but such killing/harming someone by gun is easier to do from a distance, It allows fearful people to act in a panic rather than just leaving the situation,
    The Florda man who confronted the kids over loud music was seeking a confrontation. It would have only taken him minutes to fuel the car and leave. He murdered those kids and deserves to be held accountable for it.
    (by the way, when women use “stand your ground” as a defense for domestic violence, they end up in jail. Mmm….)

  • Anne Rickert Demuth

    Mario, I think you are right in some ways although not in all. These men are acting the fool because they have a gun, yes. But I have owned fire arms for years and I don’t go around brandishing it and shooting people.Ok. I am a female so you got me there, but I was just talking with someone regarding this and I think it is more of a societal breakdown. Other countries have way more or at least as many weapons than in America, but we as a society do not properly teach our children respect, humility and to value other’s lives as we value our own. So many people are out for themselves, suffer from greed and lacking respect. That is the problem. Now I am not all peace love and hair grease either, sometimes people need to be punched in the mouth. That is a universal fact. But it takes nothing at all to shoot someone, and it is a weak and cowardly act unless you are in serious danger and your life is on the line.

  • Pingback: Michael Brown is not Trayvon Martin | Communities Digital News()