Shinseki and Carney out: Were these moves political?

Source Flickr Author Talk Radio News Service

LOS ANGELES, May 30, 2014 — In one day, two members of the Obama administration experienced their final day on the job.

In the morning, embattled Veterans’s Affairs Chief General Eric Shinseki turned in his resignation. In a more surprising move, White House Spokesperson Jay Carney stepped aside as well.

Shinseki became a lightning rod when it was discovered that problems at the VA worsened on his watch. President Obama spoke about fixing the VA before he ever became president. The person he put in charge to fix the problems, despite being a respected military general, failed in this particular mission.

The debate over Shinseki was not totally along party lines. Senate Democrats in tough reelection races wanted him out. Retired Lieutenant Colonel Ralph Peters, a Fox News military analyst with a conservative bent, passionately defended Shinseki.

Carney was another matter. His job was to spin every piece of Obama straw into gold. While this put him into ethical pretzels from time to time, he did his job with aplomb. He was effective.

The question of the timing could lead reasonable people to conclude that political motivations could be at work.

President Obama has plenty of administration officials under various controversial clouds. Attorney General Eric Holder in particular has kept his job in the face of various scandals. Obama typically shows great reluctance to fire people who are loyal to him. When people are thrown under the bus, it is when they become a political liability to him. From Reverend Jeremiah Wright to Obama’s “typical white” grandmother to Kathleen Sebelius, embarrassing President Obama personally seems to be the only qualification for falling out of favor. On-the-job performance tends to be peripheral.

As for Carney, he was not about to be indicted for anything. He was doggedly loyal, and quite good at his job of defending the indefensible. He could be burnt out. Or, perhaps Obama needed a jolt of energy heading into the 2014 elections. Current polls show Democrats facing a potential electoral bloodbath.

Only President Obama knows if his actions regarding Shinseki and Carney were pure partisan politics. The real issue is that such a strategy would not work.

Shinseki and Carney have something in common with Sebelius and every other government employee. They work for Barack Obama. He hired them. The bureaucracy did not fail him or let him down, as CNN stated. He is the bureaucracy. He runs it. He did the hiring.

The reason the Obama administration keeps being besieged by badly run departments still comes down to the criticisms leveled at Obama before he ever took office in 2009. He had no experience running any government entity. He had no experience with hiring, firing, or any other managerial functions. He ran a campaign, but that is a completely different animal.

He tends to let his ideological beliefs substitute empirical evidence. Problems are not dealt with until the crisis becomes so big that it cannot be ignored. Obama’s government is slow, reactive and ineffective. Obama ran on a campaign of change, but he stubbornly clings to the status quo until falling poll numbers force his hand.

The departures of Shinseki and Carney may be apolitical, but the evidence based on Obama’s history would suggest otherwise.

There may be more changes, but until the man at the top making the decisions changes his own management style, the problems will not be stemmed by rapid employee turnover.

Click here for reuse options!
Copyright 2014 Communities Digital News

• The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the editors or management of Communities Digital News.

This article is the copyrighted property of the writer and Communities Digital News, LLC. Written permission must be obtained before reprint in online or print media. REPRINTING CONTENT WITHOUT PERMISSION AND/OR PAYMENT IS THEFT AND PUNISHABLE BY LAW.

Correspondingly, Communities Digital News, LLC uses its best efforts to operate in accordance with the Fair Use Doctrine under US Copyright Law and always tries to provide proper attribution. If you have reason to believe that any written material or image has been innocently infringed, please bring it to the immediate attention of CDN via the e-mail address or phone number listed on the Contact page so that it can be resolved expeditiously.

  • Domenick

    Conscience got the better of Jay Carney. If Mr. Carney decides to do so, he will be the greatest “whistle blower” in America’s history.

    • Mom2Many

      Now there’s a happy thought to hold on to! Dare to dream …

      • Domenick

        Redemption, is not as far reaching as one may think.

  • jefsr


    VA Secretary is gone…. Press Secretary is gone…. Health and Human Services Secretary is gone…. HUD Secretary Nominee Julian Castro and Senator Leticia Van De Putte are named in documents turned over to Texas Ranger Bradley Freeman-Company F, FBI agent Aaron Rouse- SA office, US Attorney Steven Yarbrough- New Mexico District, the Secret Service and national
    media organizations for their part in concealing years of public/police corruption involving tens of millions of OUR dollars including HUD funds.


    The 2012 HUD fiasco that has been cited in recent media reports is very serious to say the least…BUT…the 2010 HUD cover-up where Mayor Julian Castro and other corrupt officials knowingly submitted false statements to federal inspectors to conceal years of fraud/theft in HUD-OIG case HL-10-0465 is criminal.

    CASTROGATE……Whistleblower exposes HUD Secretary Nominee Julian Castro in an unfolding HUD “cooked books” cover-up…… From 2009 to 2013 San Antonio TX Mayor Julian Castro banned whistleblowers from City Hall and public meetings to silence their reports of
    long-term public/police corruption and participated in forty-five months of illegal city council meetings….. In 2010 Castro and the City knowingly submitted false statements in HUD-OIG case # hl-10-0465 in an effort to conceal three decades of HUD fraud while federal agents played along to protect Castro In 2013 the SEC opened case # FWRO 302036 to address reports of long-term municipal bond fraud by the City…..FOIA inquiries show that the FBI has over 982 pages of documents detailing the ongoing criminal conspiracy. On Sept. 3, 2009 FBI agent D. True Bown published a fraudulent document to protect Castro and stymie any criminal
    investigation. …President Obama was provided with proof of the “cooked books” and criminal cover-up and on Nov. 17, 2009 sent a personal reply saying- “Thank you for sending me materials to review”
    but did nothing

    Contact former City Telecommunications Manager John E Foddrill Sr.
    for a CD of the documents and recordings turned over to the Secret
    Service, FBI, DOJ, HUD, etc. …[email protected]

  • jcalex

    Just like Sotomayer was Political,along with all other Barry Appointees.

  • jcalex

    Kind of like the CO of Monsanto was.

  • SoSickofObummer

    Obama does not have breakfast without considering the political implications . . . Of course this was all a political stunt!!!